I recently read in a case that “[i]t is very easy to second guess the necessity for and the amount of preparation for the trial of any matter. However, it goes without saying that better prepared lawsuits usually look simple simply because they are well prepared.” Caldwell v. Caldwell, 1988 WL 69506 (Tenn. Ct. App. 1988), 5. In the last two weeks, the Rice Team has prepared for two major trials to start and I have been amazed at the level of preparation it took to get ready.
The first way the attorneys prepared was mentally. Not only did the attorneys need to have their own arguments prepared but also had to think through every possible argument opposing counsel might throw at them. This required a lot of thought and strategy. It also required the attorneys to be ready to, at a moment’s notice, mentally comb through all the vast amounts of information they have in the case and pick out the one possibly obscure order, deposition comment, or email that would prove their argument or rebut an argument.
Besides being able to recall that the information even existed, the attorneys needed to be sure they could find it just as quickly. This is where I came in. This required a lot of copying, making charts, file folder labeling, sorting, tabbing and many other assorted activities that helped in the organization of the case.
I did not personally attend either of these particular trials, however, I have attended trial before with Larry Rice and I witnessed how this level of preparation worked and worked extremely well. Almost no time was wasted in looking for documents. Because there were copies of those documents for each person who needed them, no time was wasted in passing documents back and forth or waiting for opposing counsel to find the copy they might have had with them. If opposing counsel referenced anything, or Larry needed anything, he had it in his hand almost immediately.
One last aspect of being well-prepared, although not necessarily a tangible benefit but a benefit none-the-less, is more of an emotional one. Although the process leading up to trial and preparing for trial is stressful and anxiety –ridden, knowing when you hit the courtroom you have done everything in your power to be prepared means once you get there, you can focus solely on what is happening in front of you. Having it in their minds that they are ready and not that they will not be ready for something helps the attorneys focus on what they need to know, do and argue. This focus only helps the attorneys be even better advocates for their clients.
The level of calm that comes with being well-prepared may make it look simple to everyone in the courtroom, but the process to prepare was in no way simple at all.